Living Wills vs. Regular Wills: Which Is Right for You?
When it comes to legal planning, one of the most common questions families ask is:
What’s the difference between a living will and a regular will?
They may sound similar, but these two documents serve very different purposes—and both are essential for protecting your wishes during and after your life.
Quick Answer:
A living will outlines your medical treatment preferences if you become unable to speak for yourself. A regular will (also called a last will and testament) determines how your assets are distributed after your death. They serve different legal roles and you likely need both.
What Is a Living Will?
A living will is a legal document that spells out what types of medical treatment you want, or don’t want, if you’re seriously ill or unconscious and can’t communicate.
It can include instructions about:
- Life support or ventilator use
- Feeding tubes and hydration
- Resuscitation orders (DNR)
- Pain management and comfort care
- Organ and tissue donation
Living wills are also referred to as advance directives. They ensure your medical care aligns with your values, even if you can’t speak for yourself. They are especially critical in emergency or end-of-life situations.
Example: If you’re in a coma after a stroke and unable to make decisions, your living will helps doctors and your family understand your wishes about life-sustaining treatment.
What Is a Regular Will (Last Will and Testament)?
A regular will is a legal document that directs what happens to your property, assets, and dependents after you die.
Your will can:
- Name your heirs and beneficiaries
- Designate who receives specific items or financial accounts
- Appoint a guardian for your children or dependents
- Choose an executor to carry out your wishes
- Detail funeral or burial preferences (optional)
Unlike a living will, which is used while you’re still alive, a regular will has no legal authority until after death. It plays a vital role in ensuring your legacy is passed on according to your wishes, and it can prevent legal disputes or delays in probate.
Key Differences: Living Will vs. Regular Will
Here’s a side-by-side breakdown:
| Feature | Living Will | Regular Will |
|---|---|---|
| When It Takes Effect | While alive but incapacitated | After death |
| Main Purpose | Guides medical care decisions | Distributes property and appoints guardians |
| Controls | Life support, DNR, feeding tubes, etc. | Assets, real estate, guardianship |
| Expires | Upon death | Never—remains valid until executed in probate |
| Legal Term | Advance directive | Last will and testament |
Do You Need Both a Living Will and a Regular Will?
Yes. These documents serve completely different purposes and one does not replace the other.
- A living will protects you if you’re incapacitated but still alive.
- A regular will controls what happens after you pass away.
Together, they ensure your medical wishes and your estate plan are fully covered. Without both, your family may be left guessing, or worse, going to court.
You may have both medical and financial wishes you want respected. While a living will protects your health care choices during life, a regular will ensures your property and legacy are handled after death. If you don’t have one in place, here’s what legally happens when you die without a will, and why families are often left with stress, court delays, and avoidable conflict.
Without a living will, you risk receiving medical treatment that goes against your values.
Without a regular will, your estate may be distributed based on state law, not your intentions.
Common Misconceptions
“I have a will, so my medical wishes are covered.”
False. A regular will does not guide medical decisions or override hospital protocols.
“My family knows what I want.”
Maybe—but if your wishes aren’t in writing, doctors must default to standard treatment. Verbal instructions are not legally binding in most states.
“I’m healthy. I don’t need this yet.”
Emergencies can happen at any age. Having both documents in place gives you and your family peace of mind no matter what.
How to Create Each Document
Creating a Living Will
- Use your state’s advance directive form
- Specify your treatment preferences
- Pair it with a health care proxy, if possible
- Sign with required witnesses or notary
- Share copies with your doctors, proxy, and family
Related: What’s the Difference Between a Health Care Proxy and a Power of Attorney?
Creating a Regular Will
- List all assets and debts
- Choose beneficiaries and a trusted executor
- Designate guardians if you have minor children or dependents
- Follow state rules for signing and witnessing
- Store in a safe location and inform key people
You can draft a basic will on your own or consult an elder law attorney for a more customized plan, especially if you own property or have complex family needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a living will the same as a regular will?
No. A living will handles medical decisions while you’re alive but incapacitated. A regular will handles asset distribution after you die.
Can I have both a living will and a regular will?
Yes—and most people should. Each document serves a different purpose and protects different aspects of your life and legacy.
What happens if I don’t have a living will?
Doctors may administer all life-sustaining treatments by default. Your family may be left to make difficult decisions without knowing your wishes.
Do I need a lawyer to make a will or living will?
Not necessarily. Many states offer free forms for advance directives, and simple wills can be done at home—but legal help is recommended for complex estates.
Final Thoughts
When it comes to protecting your health, your property, and your loved ones, having both a living will and a regular will is essential. One speaks for you when you can’t. The other speaks for you after you’re gone.
It doesn’t matter how much you own or how old you are—legal planning is for everyone. Preparing these documents now can spare your family confusion, conflict, and court battles later.
Need Help Finding Free Legal Support? Check out our guide to free and low-cost legal resources for seniors, including help with wills, living wills, and advance directives.
Explore the guide here
Reference Links
- National Institute on Aging – Advance Care Planning
https://www.nia.nih.gov/health/advance-care-planning-healthcare-directives - American Bar Association – Living Wills and Advance Directives
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/law_aging/resources/health_care_decision_making/ - Nolo – What’s the Difference Between a Living Will and a Regular Will?
https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/living-will-vs-last-will.html